How a Case Gets to the US Supreme Court

المصدر
en
Mar 28, 2017 Apr 23, 2026
Video preview
مشاركة:

This article explains the process by which cases are selected for review by the US Supreme Court.

The Court System and Petitions

  • The federal court system has three layers: district (lowest), circuit (appeals), and Supreme Court (highest).
  • To reach the Supreme Court, nearly all cases require a petition for a writ of certiorari, a written request asking the Court to hear a case.
  • About 8,000 petitions are submitted each year, but only about 80 are accepted—a 1% acceptance rate.
  • How Cert is Granted

  • The Court grants cert if at least four justices (the rule of four) want to hear the case.
  • When cert is denied, it does not imply agreement with the lower court; it simply means the Court decided not to set law for the country on that issue.
  • Three Categories of Accepted Cases

  • Cases of national importance, like Bush v. Gore, which helped determine the 2000 presidential election.
  • Cases where a lower court invalidates a federal law, as in Gonzales v. Raich, where the Supreme Court upheld federal drug laws against a state medical marijuana law.
  • Cases that resolve a split among circuit courts, such as Obergefell v. Hodges, which made same-sex marriage a nationwide right by overruling conflicting circuit decisions.
  • Key Takeaways

  • No one has a right to have their case heard by the Supreme Court; acceptance is entirely at the justices' discretion.
  • Cases must raise an important question about federal law, such as the Constitution or acts of Congress.
  • The Court often takes cases to resolve conflicts between lower courts or to address issues of national importance.
  • Conclusion

    Ultimately, which cases get to the Supreme Court depends on the decisions of the sitting justices.

    لقطات بصرية تجريبي

    A black and white television screen shows a woman speaking with the text "I'll appeal to a higher court!" at the bottom. 0:10

    A black and white television screen shows a woman speaking with the text "I'll appeal to a higher court!" at the bottom.

    The text 'LOWEST LEVEL' is highlighted in yellow above the words 'District courts' in white, set against a backdrop of columns. 0:50

    The text 'LOWEST LEVEL' is highlighted in yellow above the words 'District courts' in white, set against a backdrop of columns.

    A computer screen displays the "Columbia Law School" logo and text, indicating it's a visual aid. 1:40

    A computer screen displays the "Columbia Law School" logo and text, indicating it's a visual aid.

    SFGATE logo and text "Medical pot wins a legal victory/U.S. appeals court likely to face a challenge" with a marijuana leaf superimposed on the American flag. 3:05

    SFGATE logo and text "Medical pot wins a legal victory/U.S. appeals court likely to face a challenge" with a marijuana leaf superimposed on the American flag.

    The New York Times headline reads "Justices Say U.S. May Prohibit the Use of Medical Marijuana," dated June 7, 2005. 3:32

    The New York Times headline reads "Justices Say U.S. May Prohibit the Use of Medical Marijuana," dated June 7, 2005.